Choosing between a catted and catless downpipe is a common dilemma for car enthusiasts looking to improve their engine’s performance. While both options aim to improve exhaust flow, each offers distinct advantages and potential drawbacks. In this article, we will break down the differences between these two types of downpipes, helping you determine which one is best suited for your needs.
What Is a Downpipe and Why It Matters in Engine Performance
A downpipe is an essential component of a turbocharged engine’s exhaust system. It connects the turbocharger to the rest of the exhaust system, allowing exhaust gases to flow out of the engine. The design of the downpipe plays a significant role in engine performance, particularly in turbocharged vehicles.
By improving exhaust flow, a high-performance downpipe reduces backpressure, which in turn helps the turbo spool faster and increases overall engine efficiency. This leads to more horsepower, better throttle response, and improved turbocharger performance. When modifying your vehicle, choosing the right downpipe is crucial for achieving maximum performance.
Understanding the Difference Between Catted and Catless Downpipes
The primary difference between catted and catless downpipes lies in their design. A catted downpipe includes a catalytic converter, which is responsible for reducing harmful emissions produced by the engine. The high-flow catalytic converter in these downpipes is designed to allow more exhaust gases to pass through compared to stock catalytic converters, offering a performance boost while still meeting emissions standards.
On the other hand, a catless downpipe completely eliminates the catalytic converter, allowing for maximum exhaust flow. Without a catalytic converter, the engine can expel gases much more quickly, providing a larger performance increase. However, this comes at the cost of significantly higher emissions, which may violate local regulations in certain areas.
Performance Comparison: Power Gains and Throttle Response
Catless downpipes typically provide the greatest performance gains. Removing the catalytic converter removes a significant restriction in the exhaust system, allowing exhaust gases to flow freely. This results in faster turbo spool times and increased horsepower. Power gains of up to 10-20 horsepower with proper tuning after installing a catless downpipe.
Catted downpipes, while still offering a performance improvement over stock systems, tend to provide slightly lower peak gains. However, they offer better balance, allowing for increased exhaust flow while still controlling emissions. Catted downpipes are a more practical choice for street-driven vehicles, where emissions compliance and daily drivability are priorities.
Sound, Smell, and Driving Comfort
When it comes to sound, catless downpipes produce a much louder and more aggressive exhaust note. The absence of the catalytic converter allows the exhaust gases to flow out with less resistance, creating a noticeable increase in noise. This is ideal for performance cars built for the track but may be uncomfortable for those using the vehicle as a daily driver.
Additionally, catless downpipes tend to produce a strong fuel-like smell during cold starts. This is due to unburned hydrocarbons in the exhaust that a catalytic converter would normally filter out. If you’re sensitive to this smell or plan to use the car for commuting, this could be an issue.
On the other hand, catted downpipes maintain a more controlled exhaust note. While they still provide a performance increase, the presence of the catalytic converter helps to minimize the loudness and smell. Catted downpipes also provide better comfort for daily driving, especially if you’re concerned about noise and odor.
Emissions Compliance and Inspection Readiness
One of the most significant differences between catted and catless downpipes is their impact on emissions. Catless downpipes are illegal in many states and countries due to their failure to meet emissions regulations. In areas with strict environmental laws, such as California, a catless downpipe will almost certainly cause your vehicle to fail emissions tests and may even trigger a check engine light (CEL).
In contrast, catted downpipes are designed to meet emissions standards. High-flow catted downpipes, especially those certified by CARB (California Air Resources Board), offer a legal solution for those living in states with stringent emissions laws. This makes them a more practical choice for street-driven vehicles that need to pass inspections without legal risks.
Tuning and Installation Considerations
Both catted and catless downpipes generally require some level of tuning for optimal performance. Catless downpipes often necessitate ECU adjustments or the use of O2 sensor spacers to prevent a check engine light from appearing. These adjustments ensure that the engine is running as efficiently as possible while compensating for the removal of the catalytic converter.
Catted downpipes, while less likely to trigger a CEL, may still benefit from a tune to maximize performance. Depending on the vehicle and the level of modification, you may need to reflash your ECU to ensure the engine is optimized for the increased exhaust flow.
In terms of installation, both types of downpipes require careful attention to detail. Catless downpipes may involve additional steps, such as the installation of O2 sensor adapters or custom fabrication, making them slightly more complex to install compared to catted versions.
How to Choose Between a Catted and Catless Downpipe
Choosing between a catted and catless downpipe depends on several factors, including your driving style, local regulations, and performance goals.
-
Track vs. Daily Driver: If you’re building a track car or a vehicle with minimal street use, a catless downpipe will likely provide the best performance gains. However, if you plan to drive your car daily or need to meet emissions standards, a catted downpipe is a more practical choice.
-
Emissions Regulations: If you live in an area with strict emissions laws, such as California, you may be forced to choose a catted downpipe. For others in less regulated areas, a catless downpipe may be a valid option, though it’s important to check local regulations.
-
Willingness to Deal with CEL and Legal Issues: Catless downpipes can cause a CEL and may result in failure during emissions testing. If you’re comfortable with these risks and primarily use your car for performance purposes, a catless downpipe is an option.
-
Budget: Catless downpipes are generally less expensive than catted options, but you may need to factor in additional tuning costs, installation complexity, and potential legal fees. Catted downpipes offer better long-term reliability and street legality, making them a more balanced investment.
For most users, a high-flow catted downpipe strikes a solid balance between performance and practicality. It provides notable gains in horsepower while maintaining emissions compliance and better driving comfort.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice for Your Build
In the end, the decision between a catted and catless downpipe depends largely on your individual needs. If you’re focused on maximum performance and plan to use the vehicle primarily on the track, a catless downpipe might be the right choice. However, for those looking for a more balanced option that works for street driving, emissions compliance, and comfort, a high-flow catted downpipe offers a great compromise.
Ultimately, your downpipe should match the overall goals for your vehicle build. Always consult with a professional tuner or performance shop to make sure you’re choosing the right components for your specific setup and driving requirements.
